Ahh, the first moment when a girl approaches you and acknowledges that she actually likes you. Took me until about Peter's age before it finally happened to me, and my reaction was just about as awkward as portrayed here, a sort of mix of "I can't believe a girl REALLY likes me" and "wait... is she being serious?" Poor Peter doesn't even really know how to react at this point.
Many thanks to the following folks from the Peterverse Discord for offering up their characters for cameos on this page: darkone | Kel | qjzdavf | Starfoxgalaxy248 | TsutheBookGuru | Axel | MidNight_Sparkz